I have been sharing what Captain Tom has written about attachment parenting, self-soothing, and babies being left to cry it out with moms on a different (parenting) board, and the question came up: how much crying is too much? To take my own case, with my now-4-month-old daughter, there have been times when we've tried everything and when we put her down in her crib, she howls for three minutes and then falls asleep. I think the longest she's gone crying before falling asleep was 17 minutes (I was counting, because I was going to check in at 20). We've never gone longer than 20 minutes without going back to her.
My assumption would be that there's a difference between just putting the baby in and shutting the door, especially if they're too young to really make it through the night on their own yet, and periods of "Well, she's fed, she's changed, she's burped, she's been walked, let's wait ten minutes and see what happens." But I will confess that when she was first born even 10 minutes seemed too much, for fear she would lose trust in us. So I was wondering, Captain Tom, if you could clarify a little about dealing with tired (sometimes overtired) babies without risking their future ability to self-soothe.



